Sure, it’s “just preseason.” But tell that to the Tampa Bay Lightning and Florida Panthers, who spent Tuesday night treating their exhibition clash like a midseason grudge match. Rivalries don’t care about the calendar, and this one came with some extra juice: Tampa chasing history, Florida trying to stop them, and a crowd that definitely forgot this technically doesn’t count. In the end, it was Tampa Bay flexing their depth and discipline to grind out a 3–2 win — and with it, the best preseason start in franchise history at 5-0.
The Lightning wasted no time reminding Florida whose state this is. Midway through the first, Oliver Bjorkstrand sniped a power play goal, with Darren Raddysh and Gage Goncalves helping set the table. For a Tampa squad looking for answers on special teams after last year’s inconsistencies, that early conversion was exactly the kind of preseason test drive you want to see.
But, of course, the Panthers weren’t about to let their in-state rivals steal all the shine. Just four minutes later, MacKenzie Entwistle answered back, sliding one past Jonas Johansson off helpers from Wilmer Skoog and Marek Alscher. Call it a momentum reset, call it preseason rust — either way, it set up the grind of a second period that had “next goal wins the vibe” stamped all over it.
That next goal? Belonged to Conor Geekie, who went solo mode with an unassisted strike at the 11:00 mark of the second. Less than 30 seconds later, Jakob Pelletier doubled the damage, capitalizing on slick work from Max Crozier and Emil Lilleberg. Just like that, Tampa had flipped the game from a chess match to a two-goal cushion, and Florida looked like they’d been sucker-punched.
The Panthers did claw back early in the third — Ryan McAllister cutting the deficit to 3-2 on a setup from Skoog (yes, again) and Jake Livingstone. But Johansson held firm the rest of the way, and Tampa’s penalty kill and defensive structure locked things down like they’d been playing for points.
Pelletier’s lightning-fast follow-up to Geekie’s goal was the dagger Florida never fully recovered from. Two goals in under 30 seconds is the hockey equivalent of getting dunked on and then immediately giving up a fast-break three — it’s demoralizing, it’s chaotic, and it makes the margin for error razor thin. Florida did pull within one, but mentally they never seemed to climb all the way back.
Does preseason perfection guarantee anything come April? Absolutely not. But context matters. Tampa Bay isn’t just piling up meaningless Ws — they’re getting reps for young talent, building special teams confidence, and reasserting their identity as a team that doesn’t blink when things get tense.
On the flip side, Florida’s 2-3 preseason start isn’t panic-worthy, but the sloppy penalties and inability to sustain pressure should at least raise an eyebrow. If you’re going to lose to your rival, fine. If you’re going to hand them history on a platter, that stings a little extra.
The Lightning looked like a team that doesn’t care what the calendar says — the rivalry is the rivalry. Fans felt it, the bench felt it, and the scoreboard reflected it. Geekie’s breakout moment and Bjorkstrand’s power play strike will fuel hype, but the real story is how buttoned-up Tampa’s system looked.
For Florida, it’s back to the drawing board. They get another shot Thursday in Tampa, where the Bolts will be chasing an unprecedented 6-0 start. Call it preseason, call it trivial, but make no mistake: that next matchup has receipts written all over it.
Rivalries make preseason games feel like playoff previews, and this one had just enough spice to matter. Tampa Bay didn’t just beat Florida; they announced themselves as a team that can develop youth, lean on veterans, and still out-discipline a rival. The Panthers will get their chance to punch back, but for now, it’s Lightning fans who get to walk into October with bragging rights — and a preseason record book that just got rewritten.
If this is “just preseason,” then pass the popcorn for Thursday. Because if this is the warm-up, the real show is going to be electric.